This week I want to share an excerpt from my book, Presidential Leadership: Learning from United States Presidential Libraries & Museums. The story below can be found in chapter 11, where I highlight selected leadership strengths of former United States President George H. W. Bush through true historical narrative:
“One of the first major political decisions George Bush had to make was regarding civil rights. One element of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 was a fair housing bill that would ban racial discrimination in housing. The bill came to the floor for a vote in April of 1968. At the time, Bush was a Republican representative from Texas, and many of his constituents were vehemently opposed to the bill that the Democratic president, Lyndon B. Johnson, had put before Congress. Bush was put in a difficult position with a big decision to make. He had previously campaigned in opposition to certain civil rights legislation and knew it was what his constituents expected, but at his core George Bush believed in equality. As was his nature, Bush did not take this decision lightly;
You’ve got to wrestle with your conscience. You’ve got to listen to people. It doesn’t come so easy to me that this is right and that’s wrong. It’s never that simple. The tough votes are the ones you agonize over and then you do what you think is right.
Ultimately, after weighing the pros and cons against his own personal convictions, Bush made the decision that he felt was right and voted in favor of the controversial bill.
The outrage and feeling of betrayal within his district was significant, but Bush stood behind his decision with firm conviction, appearing before a hostile crowd of booing and hissing constituents to explain his vote. Bush stood tall before the angry audience, and borrowing from philosopher Edmund Burke, said,
Your representative owes you not only his industry, but his judgment; and he betrays, instead of serving you, if he sacrifices his judgment to your opinion.
He went on to say,
I voted from conviction, not out of intimidation or fear… but because of a feeling deep down in my heart that this was the right thing for me to do.
George Bush’s speech that night was one of the most dramatic events of his political career. By calmly explaining his decision and the personal conviction behind it, Congressman Bush worked his way out of a precarious situation and left the stage that night not to the boos of the crowd, but to resounding applause.”[1]
When a leader chooses to do what is right instead of what is easy, there is no guarantee of a good outcome. When George Bush made his decision and acted out of conviction, he had no way of knowing that when he walked away that night he would do so not only with the satisfaction of knowing he had done the right thing, but also with his political future still intact. However, as a leader with steadfast strength of character, it was a risk he was willing to take.
How about you, do you lead with steadfast strength of character, no matter the odds?
If you have a short story about choosing to do what was right instead of what was easy, please share in the comments below!
To learn more about my book, what it’s about, and why I wrote it, please click here >>
To view the book on Amazon, please click here >>
Copyright © 2013 by Dan Nielsen
[1] Dan Nielsen, Presidential Leadership: Learning from United States Presidential Libraries & Museums (Dan Nielsen Company, 2013), 212-213.
Hi Dan,
I enjoy your articles and I have great respect for President Bush. However I take issue with his assertion that it is acceptable for an elected politician to deviate from the will of majority of those who elected him. I would much rather have my representatives be forthright regarding what they believe so I can vote for the one that most closely aligns with my perspective. I concede that our political culture rarely rewards candor therefore I challenge all who consider running for elected office to demonstrate their trustworthiness by genuinely representing themselves as they run for office. Those that do so and are elected would very likely have the courage required to act on those convictions, reducing the need to ‘wrestle with their conscience’ when making the tough calls.
Thank you for your comment Stuart. You have no idea how much I appreciate the fact that you took the time to express your opinions and perspectives regarding this week’s Tips for Greater Success.
You have beautifully demonstrated one of the most important and powerful realities and strengths of America – the freedom to think independently, the freedom to form independent opinions and perspectives, and the freedom to express those opinions and perspectives.
In addition, you make some excellent points, no question about it!
Thank you again for taking time to write your comments. I hope you have a wonderful and fulfilling weekend in America the beautiful.